• Home  / 
  • Debunking
  •  /  Jewish Boy Natan’s Near Death Experience: From God or Something Else?

Jewish Boy Natan’s Near Death Experience: From God or Something Else?

An Israeli boy died for 15 minutes and came back with an account of seeing Messiah, heaven, hell, and even Obama as Gog. What does it all mean and should we put any stock in it? Find out what I think is the probable source of his NDE vision...

"Tim, What About Natan's Dream?"

Emails have been coming in for a few months now asking me my opinion on a certain YouTube video. It's not your typical prophecy-theory promotion video that people want my comment on. It's the sensational testimony of a 15-year-old Israeli boy about what he saw when he died for 15 minutes. Yes, a Near Death Experience account.

Below is the loooong video in case you want to watch it yourself (in Hebrew with subtitles). You'll see the youth Natan interviewed by a rabbi named Rav Rami Levy.

In it, he relates things he saw about the future, some of which touches on familiar parts of Bible prophecy, like the Second Coming and the Gog Magog war. You'll also hear that Obama is Gog of Magog, and strangely, that the Gog Magog war already started September, 2015...(?)

Why I Tried To Ignore It

Frankly, I've been putting off writing on this video all this time not just because it's long and in Hebrew. It's simply that after two decades of encountering such tales, they hold none of fascination for me that they do for people new to this genre.

Whether you want to talk about revelations from Near Death Experiences, "my trip to Heaven/Hell" accounts, predictions of "Messiah coming soon" from non-believing Israelis (especially rabbis), or visions about the US president being some bad guy from Bible prophecy...I've seen them all many times before. There is a good reason you won't see me sharing them with my readers which will become clear as we go.

What's mildly interesting about this case for me is how Natan's story includes all of these elements mentioned above. He died, saw Messiah, President Obama, Heaven, Hell and the future and then came back to his body. This probably explains why it's getting so much attention and generating so many questions for me. It's as sensational as you can get; it has something for everyone; Jews and Christians alike.

After all, what Christian does not want to believe a secular non-believing Jew was used by God to witness to other Jews about a Messiah a lot like Jesus? And at the same time expose Obama as even worse than conservative Christians believed? =)

Summary of Natan's Vision

So what does his vision predict? Here's a list:

  1. After he died, he rose above the earth and saw a light that was full of love and security. He can’t properly explain how amazing this was.
  2. Messiah has already here and is very well known. People will be very very surprised. (He seems to be alluding to Jesus but is afraid to say it as common among Jews and Muslims. A Jewish believer told me after listening to the interview, "Natan appears to have seen Jesus the Messiah and obviously feels threatened to give a full disclosure of the event. Another interesting thing is that he saw 'Messiah' and knows who it is and everyone else knows who it is too but to his listening audience (the Jews) he tells them that they would be very, very, surprised. Natan apparently knows from his statement the "Messiah's Name" but still omits it and not shares this most important and anticipated detail??? Again, this method of obfuscation is common among Jews and Muslims. In other words they are cowardly and basically deny Him as Peter did, thrice."
  3. The war of Gog and Magog started Sept 11, 2015, and it will get much worse in the weeks or months to come.
  4. There will be a huge world war that will eventually lead the nations of the world to unite and attack Israel and Jerusalem.
  5. The leader of the free world is now Gog. Gog is none other than Barack Hussein Obama.
  6. The whole war will last only about two weeks. (oops, that would have ended Sept 25th according to 5.!)
  7. The Jews who did not keep Torah will die. The number will be in the millions. This is in addition to the non-Jews who will also perish.
  8. Mt. Zion will split into two and the Messiah will be revealed. Messiah will be able to sense by smell who is a real God-fearing Jew and who is not.
  9. Messiah will fight against Gog and kill him. Gog will be buried in Israel.
  10. During the war, two atomic bombs will be shot at Israel and God will suspend them in the air for two weeks. (They will eventually fall on Tel Aviv and Haifa.)
  11. Israel will be captured but the worthy will survive in Jerusalem.
  12. Messiah will wear a garment that is stained in blood. The blood symbolizes all the Jews who were killed while righteous. Messiah will then take revenge on the nations of the world who have oppressed us throughout the years.
  13. It will take a very long time to bury all the dead.
  14. Only those who do really repent will survive.
  15. Those who repent will inherit the highest level of heaven.
  16. The Holy Temple will descend from heaven and there will be a resurrection of the dead. This will take time and not happen immediately.
  17. It's a "matter of months" till the final redemption.

Parallels And Contradicts Prophecy

Despite my initial reluctance to look into this, I have to admit I was surprised and intrigued by part of it. Don't get me wrong, there are many things said that do not fit Bible prophecy. And I have strong doubts about the source of his vision, which I'll explain below.

For example, what obviously does not fit is that the Messiah is not "already here." Prophecy is plain about Jesus coming in the clouds a second time, from heaven. In fact, Jesus specifically warned about believing stories that the Messiah is already on earth in a secret place.

The claim that the Gog Magog war has already started months ago is also hard to fathom. Nor can I see Obama as Gog or anyone else in prophecy. It's always tempting to read the current unpopular president into prophecy, usually as the Antichrist. But it just does not fit.

Nevertheless, it's in this Gog that something surprised me. Christians do not see Gog fighting Jesus. They see him in some other pretrib war. What Natan is reporting is essentially that Gog will be the Antichrist. This is something I discovered years ago when I studied the subject, along with there being not one, but two Gog Magog Wars, 1000 years apart. (I wrote a whole chapter on it in my book.)

The other claim I am surprised to hear is the description of a nuclear attack on Israel. This is another idea I've taught for years in my book. Damascus is going to be gone from being a city as Isaiah 17 says. But it also says northern Israel ("Ephraim") is nearly gone too, along with several of the enemy nations around Israel, like Jordan (see Psalm 83). I've wondered if this does not mean Israel nukes them all in response to an unsuccessful or only partially successful nuclear assault on Israel. This lack of a Arab nuclear arsenal (so far) to answer Israel's nuclear superiority would also explain why the Arabs have not launched a fourth confederate attack (#1, 1942; #2 1967; #3, 1973) in over four decades now.

I've also said that the Arabs won't invade Israel again with just one nuclear bomb. There's too much risk in that; no fail-safe. They need more redundancy to their nuclear attack for the best chance of success; an arsenal. Perhaps they fail as prophecy says because they strike with only two, or only two get through of a few (as Natan says)?

Time will tell...but it is intriguing how a few things Natan reported are not popular prophecy interpretations yet line up with prophecy when read most literally.

So...Did He Hear From God or Not?

What do we make of his vision then? Is it of God or men(Mt 21:25)?

When people report dreams or visions they received, most people conclude one of two things about them. Either:

  1. The person fabricated it all and is lying about it for attention. (This would not be the first time this has been seen.) Or...
  2. The person is sincere and they must have heard from God.

However, I see a third explanation, one which I think applies here, especially given the hit or miss nature of the vision. He has too many true insights for it to be from the mind of man. Nevertheless, God's prophecy won't contradict previous written revelation, so it can't be from God. That leaves the other part of the supernatural world as the source:

"Depart From Me, I Never Knew you!" - Jesus

Jesus' predicted he will tell many sincere believers basically to "get lost" instead of welcoming them into the Kingdom. So...who are they and what did they miss or do wrong? In this study, get those answers and the one requirement for salvation Jesus taught (that Christianity misses) so that you can make sure you don't hear these dreaded words yourself!

  1. Spirits disobedient to God, fallen angels and demon have inspired the person.

"Test The Spirits"

Christians doubt that people can hear or be inspired by demons (let alone possessed). Scripture says otherwise, both in the OT and NT. I'll give two quick examples, although the subject deserves an entire article of its own.

One of my favorite stories in the Bible is the OT example of this. In 1 Kings 22 the wicked King Ahab of Israel is enticed by the prophets of Baal to believe he will be victorious if he attacks Aram. God's prophet Micaiah disagrees and predicts defeat. To explain why Baal's prophets said the opposite, Micaiah shares a rather disturbing vision of heaven he saw.

In it, God asked the council in heaven who would entice Ahab to fight Aram and die (1Ki 22:20). A lying spirit came forward and said it would do it. "How?" God asked. He explained he would speak lies through Baal's prophets. God agreed and sent him to do it (1Ki 22:22).

Shocking, but true. God did nothing wrong here, though. Ahab was wicked and if he was going to consult and trust in false prophets, God was going to use that sinful choice to bring judgment on him for his great wickedness.

The story proves that demons can inspire prophecies, whisper into human minds. But is it only possible with wicked people? What about innocent atheists, or even lukewarm Christians? Or true servants of God?

In the NT, servants of God are warned not to believe every spirit, but to test them because many false prophets have gone out into the world (1 John 4:1). This means don't assume when you get a dream or a word that it had to have come from God. We are to learn to discern. Unfortunately this means even when you're praying to God alone to speak to you, he does not cut off other voices from replying, too. God allows this to test us, and help us to learn his voice (Dt 13:1-3).

Demonic spirit inspiration is how I understand and explain most Near Death Experiences (NDEs). The evil spirits know that someone coming back from the dead will receive a lot of attention. What better way to spread lies than to plug into that person when they are weak and vulnerable and deliver a false vision? If the vision has a healthy amount of truth mixed in, then the lies are much harder to see and discern.

"A More Sure Word of Prophecy"

When I was young, like many of you I was intrigued by these NDE testimonies. Also the prophecies of Nostradamus, testimonies of Christians about heaven, and the like. As time went on, I saw they were inconsistent and unreliable and I stopped paying attention to them.

Then my childhood interest in Bible prophecy was reignited by hearing an intriguing new explanation for Mystery Babylon. I always believed from teachings at church that Babylon was the Vatican. This new explanation took many more verses and show how they plainly fit America. I realized it was America all along but I had settled for a lesser answer that required me to ignore and twist the verses I now could see literal fulfillment in America. Something had never set quite right about that Vatican answer, and now I finally understood why, seeing the right answer. The True McCoy exposes the counterfeit. I was delighted to finally have an answer that made sense.

In the course of a couple years, I went on to build upon that foundational truth and literal approach with more plain and literal explanations of hard questions and passages of Revelation, such as Wormwood. (That one blew Revelation wide open; not surprising given it makes up 6 of the 21 seals, trumpets and bowls). It just all fell into place easily and joyfully. It was thrilling! Since I could not keep such exciting findings all to myself, I wrote my book for others who, like me, wanted better answers than they got in church, too.

Perhaps now you can understand more fully why I was so reluctant to write about an NDE like Natan's. Once you understand what real, honest-to-God-inspired Bible prophecy has been saying all along, you won't have any interest in extra-biblical revelations, either. When people ask me why I'm not interested in conspiracy theories, prophecy theories or prophetic words on the internet, I often quote this verse to them:

2Pt 1:19 — We have also a more sure word of prophecy; whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the day star arise in your hearts

When you live in a time when we can finally understand the once-sealed Words of God's holy prophets plainly and literally (Dan 12:4) as Jesus wished for his servants (Rev 1:1), why bother with the words and testimonies of unconfirmed prophets and other counterfeits like are shared all over the Internet?

If you are ready to understand prophecy like never before, my book is available to help you do that. Feel free to email me (links at top and bottom) with any questions before and, of course, any questions on the book after. It would be my pleasure to help you if you are done with false prophecies and serious about understanding the sure word of Bible prophecy we have open to us now.

Receive Tim's Prophecy Updates By Email

Join 30,000 subscribers receiving Tim's new articles and updates by email. Understanding Bible prophecy better will dispel your end time fear and bless you (Rev 1:3).

About the author

Tim McHyde

Tim is the author of this site (since 1999) and the book Know the Future that explains Revelation literally at last--including the key event of Wormwood (Rev 6-8). To read more from Tim and not miss a single new article, sign up for his free newsletter above.

5 comments
DL - January 15, 2017

Good article.

The verse you couldn’t find the reference for, was it Deuteronomy 13:1-3?

Reply
Linda - April 5, 2017

A 3rd option for a dream or vision is Satan incognito. Maybe Natan means Jesus is here as Holy Spirit?

Reply
    Tim McHyde - April 5, 2017

    Linda, the third option was already there in the text, but not as part of the numbered list, so I modified that for clarity. Thanks for the comment. GMTA =)

    Reply
Tom Cash - May 1, 2017

I had just come across this boys video somehow today and some of if it gave me pause so when I did a little searching …look who popped up but my friend Tim! Loved your explaination especially about all the spirits trying to speak to us!

Thank you !

Reply
Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: